| Name | | Relations | Birth | Date of death | Age | Vet Status | Marker | Marker Condition | Notes |
|
| Eliza B. Jellerson | | | | | 1825? | 83 | | | Marble; broken | |
|
| Guy K. Preslie | | | Son of Ben/Marcia | | 05/28/1896 | 1 | | | Marble; broken | |
|
| Macia M. Preslie | | | Wife of Ben | | 02/22/1896 | 18 | | | Marble; placed on base 9/98 | |
|
| Alice Tibbetts | | | | | N/A | 78 | | | Marble; recemented into key 9/98 | |
|
| Ann M. Tibbetts | | | | | 1850? | 8 | | | Marble; recemented into key 9/98 | |
|
| Annette Tibbetts | | | Daughter of Mark/Lydia | | 02/08/1852 | 9 mos. | | | Marble double stone fallen with Frank | |
|
| Frank Tibbetts | | | Son of Mark/Lydia | | 10/07/1867 | 5 | | | Marble double stone fallen with Annette | |
|
| Hattie Tibbetts | | | | | 1871? | 7 | | | Marble; on base 9/98 | |
|
| James Tibbetts | | | | | N/A | 15 | | | Marble; recemented into key 9/98 | |
|
| Jason Tibbetts | | | | | 1849? | 26 | | | Marble; recemented 9/98 | |
|
| John Tibbetts | | | | | N/A | 20 | | | marble; clear but worn | |
|
| Lydia A. Tibbetts | | | Wife of Mark | | 8/13/1900 | 66 | | | Marble; broken | |
|
| Mark Tibbetts | | | | | 12/20/1900 | 69 | | | Marble; broken | |
|
| Mary Tibbetts | | | Wife of William | | 06/20/1842 | 55 | | | Marble recemented 9/98 | |
|
| Nancy Tibbetts | | | | | N/A | 24 | | | Marble; tilted | |
|
| Sally T. Tibbetts | | | | | 03/20/1872 | 53 | | | Marble; broken | |
|
| Unknown Tibbetts | | | (infant) | | N/A | 0 | | | Marble; Broken | |
|
| William T. Tibbetts | | | | | 11/20/1877 | 88 | | | Marble; recemented into key 9/98 | |
|
| William Capt. Tibbetts | | | | | N/A | 75 | | | Marble; tilted but sound 8/98 | |